• If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!


Disputed Pages

Page history last edited by Tim 15 years, 10 months ago

Back to the Main Page

Disputed Pages

If you think an article is unfit for the wiki, don't just post it on Requests for Deletion or overwrite it.

Instead, give it a chance by creating a Disputed Article Discussion page. Start by adding a header to the page using this template:

This article's {'subject'} is Disputed. See its {'link to discussion page'} for details.

Replace {'subject'} with the aspect of the article you find unfit (its veracity, relevance, etc.). The name of the linking page should be the article's name + (disputed). For example: James Bort (disputed)

"(discussion)" is also acceptable.

Add its link to this page and let the community decide what to do. After a conclusion has been reached (no flame wars, please), move the link below the "Archived Disputed Pages" header on this page, in order to preserve past discussions for future reference.

Currently Disputed Pages

Archived Disputed Pages

All comments previously on this page have been moved to their appropriate discussion pages. I hope this page will smooth out the process of removing inappropriate pages. Thank you for your participation! ~Lucres

I think that where possible we should create in character discussion pages and create as plausible in character resolutions for disputes as possible. My changes to the James Bort page are a good example of what I mean. - Xaph
Agreed. The Out of Character stuff should be reserved for offensive and problematic pages, like The Roig Syndrome. Otherwise, if you just find something lame, it can easily be couched in other terms. Dan
In my opinion, all disputes here can be handled In Character. I have yet to see a dispute that demanded OOC intervention. Every "OOC" page detracts from the atmosphere and fuels the conspiracy theories. Just be creative. -Belda
Roig couldn't have been handled in character. Or at least I'm not smart enough to know how. I have no idea how we could have talked around that one. -patkelly

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.